The Endless Quest Collectors Set #2 (Collection)
Buntut na dzhudzhetata [Бунтът на джуджетата] (Bulgarian)
Dowaafu no hanran [ドワーフの反乱] (Japanese)
Der Kampf der Zwerge (German)
La rebelión de los enanos (Spanish)
A revolta dos Duendes (Portuguese)
La Révolte des nains (French)
La rivolta dei nani (Italian)
Holloway, James (Jim) (interior)
0880380209 / 9780880380201
157 pages |
|Number of Endings:||
|User Summary:||Rebellious dwarves separate you from your parents, forcing you to attempt to survive on your own and perhaps dabble in politics.|
This little D&D inspired CYOA-styled book is a bit too coy for its own good. I imagine the target audience is an eight year old boy, sure. But even for said demographic, the adventure may prove mildly entertaining, but only just. Even a young boy might be bored with the subject matter here. One spends more time talking to giddy pixies and dealing with a puppy, rather than outwitting nasty dwarves and staving off an actual rebellion. The challenge is very simple as well... I hit upon the best ending via my first path through. While not a terrible CYOA-esque fling, Revolt of The Dwarves squanders its D&D subject matter too flippantly for my taste. The author didn't seem to understand her source inspiration or demographic well at all.
While there are a lot of different paths in this book, I just found it to be rather boring. The political intrigue isn't very intriguing, the dwarves aren't portrayed very well (especially in the illustrations), and the adventure is mostly uneventful.
In this book, you play Galen, the son of the royal mapmaker whose parents are kidnapped by the disloyal dwarves.
This is another book where you play a kid, which is fine with me. In fact, in this one, you are on your own without adults, so you really can't rely on fighting but brains.
There are three distinct paths you can take. A somewhat boring one with the dwarves. A fun one with pixies. And most interestingly a Huck Finn type river journey with another boy. So this book has high replay value as well as a grand mission (save the kingdom).
The interior art is awesome, with a particularly cute pixie girl and dryad, as well as lizardmen and the like.
These books are pretty sexless, but this one has an amazing seduction passage where a dryad sexes so much you turn into a tree. As a kid, it went completely over my head but it's still an interesting concept.
Overall, another solid offering from Estes.
I reread this book and have mixed feelings about it.
For such a small book, there really is a large variety of choices of places to go and things to do -- search for the dwarves, hang out in the forest, try to find the prince, etc. Each path has a lot of choices and each one does have it's own distinct adventure... yet I just don't seem to be too drawn into it.
Maybe it is because I am much older reading it now, but something just prevents me from caring about trying all the alternatives. The story is good...but perhaps the 'you are a little kid with his puppy' setup saps some of my strength!
Still, if you are new to Endless Quest, I would certainly recommend giving this a try.
One tidbit I recalled from reading this as a kid was the dryad that seduces you and then turns you into a tree!
Not a bad book, but IMO, the writing takes a step back from the previous two books. Here, the writing feels rushed and the pace is a little off. I spent most of the book with pixies. The major choices occur early on, I think, and replayability should be high. But for me, too many choices centered on things extraneous to the main quest, with the final resoluation coming in a very hurried manner. Quite a few choices are not real choices as well, with certain options simply leading where others lead anyway.
I will echo Demian's thoughts concerning the interior illustrations of the dwarves... not exactly spot-on where D&D is concerned.
For me, this book represents a step or two backwards in the series.
Rating 1-10: 5
|Users Who Own This Item:||Alatar001, Ardennes, auximenes, B0N0V0X, bigcobra, bonhomme, bookwormjeff, Chanticrow, convict7421, Crazyscotsman, CSquared, Cyan, damieng, dArtagnan, dave2002a, Demian, duckhugger, EegahInc, Erikwinslow, exaquint (bar top), Ffghtermedic, fushek, Garrick Muttley, Greeneuva, gryff, Gurvo (1st print), hadlee73, hoops4ever, Icedlake, JoshW, Jubal, katatonius, katzcollection, Khellendros, killagarilla, killagirilla, kinderstef, knginatl ("pick-a-path" & bar top), Kveto, Lambchop, le maudit, LordJR, MacbthPSW, mattender, mcd, mlvoss, momaw27, Morthynmir, nelsondesign, NEMO, Nomad, noonxnoon, ntar (1st cover), outspaced, peterm2, plowboy, Pseudo_Intellectual, redpiper05, ryderark (Spanish Timun Mas), Ryuran333, Sheridan77, SherlockHolmes, spragmatic, ThaRid, ThisIslandEarth, toadhjo, twar, utfanatic, Virtua Sinner, Wampic, wonderfly, Yalius, zat|
|Users Who Want This Item:||exaquint (pick), Grifter, hanbaoge, jeremydouglass, snakefire77, stock, Trachalio (Used to own)|
|Users with Extra Copies:||
exaquint - bar top
ntar - 2
twar - Second printing. Creased front/back covers. Name penned on inside of front cover.
Please log in to manage your collection or post a review.