Item - Talent Showdown

[Rating: 2/10]
[Recommended? NO]

First and foremost, I have to mention that these are NOT interactive stories or gamebooks - the Pokémon Chapter Books are commercial tie-ins to the (early seasons of the) Pokémon anime, which in and of itself served as a companion to the games many know and love. For the sake of reviewing these books with regards to their historical value and contributory merits in the broader scope of interactive literature - as this site is dedicated toward the preservation and legacy of - my assessments are therefore accomplished with the intention of remarking upon these books' status/quality from that perspective.

It is quite easy to see what appeals about these little chapter books on the surface level - they faithfully recreate the scenes and depictions of one or more episodes of the Pokémon anime. And the general tone of "Talent Showdown" is largely successful in doing what it sets out to do - and serves as an excellent example of what an adaptation can accomplish in recreating the overall feel of a story from another medium. That being understood, something feels missing throughout the work - perhaps a miscalculated sense of longevity, or a bit of overdependence on the source material - and as result, the whole works ends up coming across as a misfire... all due to the lack of grander ambition.

As such, it isn't easy to strongly recommend this title to broader audiences (though some readers won't mind the familiar sentiments and enjoyable tone) - which is a real shame, since this book had more potential than it took advantage of. ^^

(Mysteriously disappears into the shadows.)

More reviews by Shadeheart